Showing 1–100 of 132 results

Filters
Price filter
    Filter by color
    Filter by size
      $25 Gift Card - I Still Love You NYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      $25 Gift Card

      $ 25.00
      $10 Gift Card - I Still Love You NYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      $10 Gift Card

      $ 10.00
      $50 Gift Card - I Still Love You NYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      $50 Gift Card

      $ 50.00
      $100 Gift Card - I Still Love You NYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      $100 Gift Card

      $ 100.00
      MYSTERY BAG! - I Still Love You NYC - 1
      -33%
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop

      MYSTERY BAG!

      $ 150.00 $ 100.00
      LOUDMOUTH EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LOUDMOUTH EARRINGS

      $ 125.00
      LOUDMOUTH EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LOUDMOUTH EARRINGS

      $ 125.00
      MOON & STARS EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      MOON & STARS EARRINGS

      $ 65.00
      Drip Splat Earrings Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Drip Splat Earrings

      $ 40.00
      3
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      3" Circle Square Earrings

      $ 30.00
      CIRCLE CHOKER Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      CIRCLE CHOKER

      $ 35.00
      Medium Hoop Earrings Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Medium Hoop Earrings

      $ 30.00
      SPLASHES GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SPLASHES GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      IRIDESCENT S2F CHOKER Necklace ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      IRIDESCENT S2F CHOKER

      $ 75.00
      2
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      2" Circle Square Earrings

      $ 25.00
      LONG PETAL FRINGE EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      LONG PETAL FRINGE EARRINGS

      $ 150.00
      PETAL FRINGE EARRING Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      PETAL FRINGE EARRING

      $ 65.00
      PETAL FRINGE EAR HOOK Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      PETAL FRINGE EAR HOOK

      $ 30.00
      TENNIS ANYONE? CHOKER Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      TENNIS ANYONE? CHOKER

      $ 50.00
      SMALL EYE EARRING Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SMALL EYE EARRING

      $ 40.00
      TENNIS ANYONE? MEDIUM NECKLACE Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      TENNIS ANYONE? MEDIUM NECKLACE

      $ 45.00
      SHIELD GLASSES - ACRYLIC TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      SHIELD GLASSES - ACRYLIC TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      TENNIS ANYONE? GLASSES LANYARD Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      TENNIS ANYONE? GLASSES / MASK LANYARD

      $ 65.00
      CUSTOM NAME NECKLACE Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      CUSTOM NAME NECKLACE

      $ 40.00
      STAR GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC IRIDESCENT
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      STAR GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      Star Drop Earrings Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Star Drop Earrings

      $ 50.00
      Modern Scarab Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Modern Scarab

      $ 40.00
      LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      ROUND GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      ROUND GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      ARC GLASSES - IRIDESCENT Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      ARC GLASSES - IRIDESCENT

      $ 75.00
      DRIP CHOKER - IRIDESCENT Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DRIP CHOKER - IRIDESCENT

      $ 75.00
      MEDIUM EYE EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      MEDIUM EYE EARRINGS

      $ 50.00
      SMALL SINGLE SQUARE EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SMALL SINGLE SQUARE EARRINGS

      $ 20.00
      CAITLIN EARRING Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop
      BlackRose gold

      CAITLIN EARRING

      $ 40.00
      CHELSEA EARRING Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      CHELSEA EARRING

      $ 40.00
      DIET BLAIR - CONFETTI Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DIET BLAIR - CONFETTI

      $ 30.00
      DONNA EARRING Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DONNA EARRING

      $ 30.00
      LONG STICK - CONFETTI Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - CONFETTI

      $ 20.00
      LONG STICK - WHITE Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - WHITE

      $ 20.00
      LONG STICK - BLACK Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - BLACK

      $ 20.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - CONFETTI Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - CONFETTI

      $ 20.00
      SMALL EYE EARRING - BLACK & GOLD Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SMALL EYE EARRING - BLACK & GOLD

      $ 40.00
      ALIEN ID CHOKER - IRIDESCENT Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      ALIEN ID CHOKER - IRIDESCENT

      $ 50.00
      CIRCLE CHOKER - BLACK Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      CIRCLE CHOKER - BLACK

      $ 35.00
      BLAIR EARRINGS Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      BLAIR EARRINGS

      $ 35.00
      SPACE CAT GLASSES - ACRYLIC TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop
      IridescentRust

      SPACE CAT GLASSES - ACRYLIC TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      Squiggle Glasses - Smoke Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Squiggle Glasses - Smoke

      $ 100.00
      Squiggle Glasses - Acid Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Squiggle Glasses - Acid

      $ 100.00
      Squiggle Glasses - Neon Pink Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      Squiggle Glasses - Neon Pink

      $ 100.00
      SQUIGGLE GLASSES - IRIDESCENT Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SQUIGGLE GLASSES - IRIDESCENT

      $ 100.00
      DIAMOND EYES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DIAMOND EYES

      $ 75.00
      DR OCTAGON SUNNIES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DR OCTAGON SUNNIES

      $ 75.00
      DRIPPING HEARTS Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DRIPPING HEARTS

      $ 75.00
      SKINNY GAGE EARRINGS - IRIDESCENT EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SKINNY GAGE EARRINGS - IRIDESCENT

      $ 50.00
      IRIS EARRINGS EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      IRIS EARRINGS

      $ 50.00
      IRIS - SMOL EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      IRIS - SMOL

      $ 40.00
      DAKOTA EARRINGS EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DAKOTA EARRINGS

      $ 65.00
      JUDY EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      JUDY

      $ 50.00
      JUDY - SMOL EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      JUDY - SMOL

      $ 40.00
      TINY FRIENDS EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      TINY FRIENDS

      $ 75.00
      RISING SUN EARRINGS EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      RISING SUN EARRINGS

      $ 75.00
      DAKOTA EARRING SMOL EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DAKOTA EARRING SMOL

      $ 50.00
      GATES NECKLACE NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      GATES NECKLACE

      $ 150.00
      THICK GAGE NECKLACE - IRIDESCENT NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      THICK GAGE NECKLACE - IRIDESCENT

      $ 75.00
      SKINNY GAGE CHOKER - IRIDESCENT NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      SKINNY GAGE CHOKER - IRIDESCENT

      $ 60.00
      ZIGGURAT NECKLACE NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      ZIGGURAT NECKLACE

      $ 125.00
      FRIENDSHIP CHOKER NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      FRIENDSHIP CHOKER

      $ 50.00
      FRIENDS WITH BENEFITS NECKLACE NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      FRIENDS WITH BENEFITS NECKLACE

      $ 60.00
      DAKOTA RISING NECKLACE NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      DAKOTA RISING NECKLACE

      $ 200.00
      GAGE BRACELET - IRIDESCENT BRACELET ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      GAGE BRACELET - IRIDESCENT

      $ 50.00
      JOANNA LANYARD LANYARD ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      JOANNA GLASSES /MASK LANYARD

      $ 45.00
      POPPY LANYARD LANYARD ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      POPPY GLASSES / MASK LANYARD

      $ 65.00
      UV SPLASHES GLASSES GLASSES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      UV SPLASHES GLASSES

      $ 125.00
      UV STAR GLASSES GLASSES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      UV STAR GLASSES

      $ 125.00
      UV DRIPPING HEART GLASSES GLASSES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      UV DRIPPING HEART GLASSES

      $ 125.00
      PAPER PLANE GLASSES GLASSES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      PAPER PLANE GLASSES

      $ 175.00
      SKINNY GAGE NECKLACE - EMERALD NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SKINNY GAGE NECKLACE - EMERALD

      $ 60.00
      GAGE NECKLACE - EMERALD NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      GAGE NECKLACE - EMERALD

      $ 75.00
      SKINNY GAGE EARRINGS - EMERALD EARRINGS ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SKINNY GAGE EARRINGS - EMERALD

      $ 50.00
      GAGE BRACELET - EMERALD BRACELET ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      GAGE BRACELET - EMERALD

      $ 50.00
      LONG STICK - IRIDESCENT Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - IRIDESCENT

      $ 20.00
      LONG STICK - ROSE GOLD Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - ROSE GOLD

      $ 20.00
      LONG STICK - SILVER Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      LONG STICK - SILVER

      $ 20.00
      LONG STICK - GEMTONES Earrings ISLYNYC
      -16%
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop
      Gimme all 6!GarnetRubyCitrineEmeraldSapphireAmethyst

      LONG STICK - GEMTONES

      $ 20.00 – $ 100.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - IRIDESCENT Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - IRIDESCENT

      $ 20.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - ROSE GOLD Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - ROSE GOLD

      $ 20.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - GEMTONES Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop
      GarnetRubyCitrineEmeraldSapphireAmethyst

      SHORT STICK EARRING - GEMTONES

      $ 20.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - SILVER Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - SILVER

      $ 20.00
      ALIEN ID CHOKER - ROSE GOLD Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      ALIEN ID CHOKER - ROSE GOLD

      $ 50.00
      ALIEN ID CHOKER - SILVER Necklaces ISLYNYC
      Sold out
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Read more

      ALIEN ID CHOKER - SILVER

      $ 50.00
      DIET HOOP Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DIET HOOP

      $ 20.00
      SMOKE LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SMOKE LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      DRIPPING HEARTS - ROSE Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DRIPPING HEARTS - ROSE

      $ 75.00
      ZODIAC EARRINGS! Earrings ISLYNYC PISCES
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Quick Shop

      ZODIAC EARRINGS!

      $ 20.00
      DIET BLAIR - IRIDESCENT Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      DIET BLAIR - IRIDESCENT

      $ 30.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - WHITE Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - WHITE

      $ 20.00
      SHORT STICK EARRING - BLACK Earrings ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      SHORT STICK EARRING - BLACK

      $ 20.00
      RUST LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      RUST LIQUID CAT EYE - METAL TEMPLES

      $ 75.00
      ZIGGURAT NECKLACE RAINBOW NECKLACES ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      ZIGGURAT NECKLACE RAINBOW

      $ 150.00
      PREORDER STAR GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES - RUST Glasses ISLYNYC
      Quick ViewQuick View
      Close
      Add to cart

      STAR GLASSES - METAL TEMPLES - RUST

      $ 75.00